In Whiddon v Fire and Rescue NSW [2026] NSWIRComm 1118 the Industrial Relations Commission confirmed that a worker can be fairly dismissed for an out of work criminal offence.

In this case senior firefighter Whiddon was convicted of an indecent assault.  The incident occurred in 2018, and he was charged in 2023. He entered a plea of not guilty but was convicted by a jury in July 2024.  The maximum penalty was 5 years imprisonment, but the actual penalty imposed was a 3-years community corrections order. The applicant was suspended on pay from 15 January 2023. That was changed to suspension without pay in May 2025.  On 7 November 2025 Fire and Rescue wrote to Mr Whiddon inviting submissions as to why he should not be directed to resign. Submissions were made but on 26 February 2026 he was directed to resign within 7 days or he would be dismissed. Mr Whiddon did not resign so his employment was terminated on 6 March 2026.  He brought this application arguing that the dismissal was unfair ([4]).

Without reporting all the arguments, the Tribunal confirmed that the decision to dismiss Mr Whiddon was not unfair. The Tribunal said (at [39]-[41]):

The Fire Brigades Regulation 2023 (the “FB Regulation”) at cl 36 provides that if a firefighter is convicted of a serious offence, which is defined in subcl 36(3)(a) as an offence punishable by 12 months imprisonment or more, that the Respondent may do one of the following:

(a) take disciplinary action against the firefighter in accordance with the procedural guidelines, or

(b) take remedial action against the firefighter, or

(c) take action against the firefighter under section 34 as if the firefighter had been found to have engaged in misconduct.

Similarly, Part 7 of the Respondent’s Procedural Guidelines for the Management of Conduct (the “Guidelines”) provides that an employee found guilty of a serious criminal charge is considered to have engaged in misconduct.

Thus, there is no doubt that the Conviction constituted misconduct and provided a proper basis for the Respondent to consider whether the Applicant should be dismissed from his employment. However, it does not provide an automatic basis for dismissal.

As stated above in Walsham, very serious crimes, particularly those involving violence or sexual offences, will generally justify dismissal, even if committed outside of working hours. The Applicant was convicted of indecent assault, which falls within the scope of a sexual offence and as such provides another reasonable basis for the dismissal.

And at [47]-[49]:

Firefighters whilst performing their duties can be called upon to enter private homes, schools and other buildings and deal with vulnerable people whilst unsupervised. The Applicant’s failure to understand and acknowledge the gravity of the offence for which he was convicted strongly supports the conclusion that he cannot presently be entrusted with this role in which integrity and public confidence are fundamental requirements.

Finally, I accept the Respondent’s submissions concerning the reputational risk caused by the Applicant’s misconduct, particularly so given evidence adduced during cross-examination that the decision with respect to the Applicant’s conviction is available on the internet.

For the above reasons, I do not accept the Applicant’s submissions that the decision to dismiss him was disproportionate and for this reason was not unreasonable nor harsh.

The Tribunal did accept that there had been some denial of natural justice as the decision maker said that he had considered ‘that the Applicant had contravened the Respondent’s sexual harassment policy and that he also had a concern about the psychosocial risk in relation to the Applicant returning to work’ ([14]).  These particular issues had not been put to Mr Whiddon so he had been denied the opportunity to address them. Further it was admitted in the Commission that ‘the Applicant had not contravened the sexual harassment policy and that there was no psychosocial risk assessment undertaken’ ([15]). The Commission said ([50]-[54] references omitted):

It is trite law that a failure to afford procedural fairness may render a dismissal unfair in and by itself. However, not every case of where there was a lack of procedural fairness involved in a dismissal will render it harsh, unreasonable or unjust, given the seriousness of the misconduct established on the evidence.

…

Except for the alleged breach of the sexual harassment policy and the psychosocial risks identified by Mr McGuiggan, when regard is had to the totality of the process, including the suspension, the Applicant was put on notice of the fundamental issues identified by Mr McGuiggan in paragraph [13] of this decision that he was considering.

As to the two other reasons, being the breach of the sexual harassment policy and the psychosocial risks, the evidence does not disclose that the Applicant was given an opportunity to respond to those. With respect to these two reasons, I find that the Applicant was denied procedural fairness.

Although the Applicant was denied procedural fairness, I find that it is insufficient to make the Dismissal unfair as the other reasons for which the Applicant was provided an opportunity to respond to weigh overwhelmingly in support of the Dismissal…

As for whether the decision was ‘harsh’ the Commission said (at [56]-[57]):

Almost all dismissals will occasion hardship upon an individual who has been removed from their employment, but that does not make all dismissals harsh to the extent that it renders that dismissal unfair…

Firstly, the Applicant has not proven that he will suffer any financial loss which has or will be occasioned by the Dismissal given his electrical contracting business.

Secondly, although the Applicant has had a reasonably lengthy period of unblemished service, the seriousness of the misconduct outweighs any harshness that may be occasioned to the Applicant by the Dismissal.

The decision to dismiss Mr Whiddon after 18 years’ service with NSW Fire and Rescue ([13]) was confirmed.

This blog is a general discussion of legal principles only.  It is not legal advice. Do not rely on the information here to make decisions regarding your legal position or to make decisions that affect your legal rights or responsibilities. For advice on your particular circumstances always consult an admitted legal practitioner in your state or territory.