Today’s correspondent is

… a paramedic working in occupational health.

I am an authorised health practitioner (AHP) under the rail industry worker (RIW) program. This means I can signed off Cat 3 rail medicals. My colleagues (RNs) are not AHP. A doctor who works at my company is also the Chief Medical Officer for two major rail companies that we provide Cat 1, Cat 2 and Cat 3 rail medicals for.

My colleagues are being booked in to do Cat 3 rails (as well as Cat 1 and 2s), they have been writing notes on the file “not AHP accredited”. Both this Dr as well as admin staff from my company’s rail team have advised them to get me to sign the Cat 3’s. I am not comfortable doing this. What is my legal standpoint to decline?

The Rail Industry Worker program is explained here – https://www.queenslandrail.com.au/forbusiness/contractors/Railworkers

Details of the Authorised Health Professionals Program is found here – https://www.riw.net.au/authorised-health-professionals/. There are extensive steps to becoming an AHP – see https://ahpprogram.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/Steps-to-become-an-Authorised-Health-Professional.pdf.

The program website (https://ahpprogram.com.au/about-us/) says

To ensure there is a consistent approach across the Australian rail industry, the National Standard for Health Assessment of Rail Safety Workers (the Standard) was developed and is regularly reviewed and updated. Authorised Health Professionals (AHPs) are accredited to undertake these medical assessments in accordance with the Standard.

Other health professionals may be competent to conduct a health assessment but they are not accredited to undertake this assessment and ensure a consistent approach. As it says here (https://www.riw.net.au/authorised-health-professionals/) ‘All rail medical assessments must be performed by an Approved Authorised Health Professional (AHP) listed in the AHP directory. Medicals conducted and signed by AHPs not listed in this directory will be rejected’.

If my correspondent relies on the work of others then he or she is in effect certifying that the other practitioner has conducted the assessment as required and in accordance with the training. That is clearly not what is intended. It is intended that AHPs will conduct the rail medical assessment.

Many programs exist where an authorised person supervises others, so an AHP may be assisted by another professional to take observations or perform some tasks but by signing off the AHP is saying that he or she is personally satisfied that the tests were properly performed and the results are as recorded. At the end of the day it is the AHP that is certifying that the person meets the requirements and, in this case, that the assessment has been done using the ‘consistent approach’.

I can imagine a situation where an AHP can say ‘I lead a team of professionals and when someone comes in the nurse takes some observations (bp, pulse etc) then passes that to me and I do whatever else has to be done and a physio takes them through the exercise and reports back and I sign off’.  But I cannot see how it can be possible for anyone to say ‘I am meant to certify a person is fit but I’ve never met them and I see a report from someone else who tells me they assessed them and that is all I go on’.   If any health practitioner can do the assessment they would say that and clearly that is not intended.

So without going into legal advice, and taking a broad view, not just the rail program, if you are an accredited assessor in any field then you are being asked to do the relevant assessment and give your opinion whether the assessment is satisfactory. No-one in their right mind would simply sign off because someone else has done the assessment and told you it’s ‘good to go’.

If in the circumstances described my correspondent is not comfortable signing off on the document then don’t sign off on it. You are being asked to give your assessment.

This blog is a general discussion of legal principles only.  It is not legal advice. Do not rely on the information here to make decisions regarding your legal position or to make decisions that affect your legal rights or responsibilities. For advice on your particular circumstances always consult an admitted legal practitioner in your state or territory.